GR9677 #15


Problem


This problem is still being typed. 
Thermodynamics}Phase Diagram
Recall that for an ideal gas and . Don't forget the first law of thermodynamics, .
For , , since the temperature is constant. Thus, .
For , . , and thus .
For , , , thus .
Add up all the Q's from above, cancel the term, to get , as in choice (E).s


Alternate Solutions 
ssp 20080908 03:26:43  3step cycle with isovolumetric part that has W = 0, so we need an added heat for two steps (read two parts). That already eliminates (A) through (C). Then for the last part just dimensional analysis... (D) does not work cause we are missing a mass to convert the to joules.... that only leaves (E)  

Comments 
nirav_605 20131016 12:44:43  In Process from B to C
Isn't that suppose to be C_p not C_v
The process occurs at constant pressure not volume.
Giuseppe 20150911 15:04:33 
For the isobar BC you have to use C_p for the heat absorbed (Q) and C_v for the change in internal energy (U), since the change in internal energy in BC has to be equal and opposite to that of CA.\r\nInfact, for BC:\r\nQ = Cp(ThTl)\r\nU = Cv(ThTl)\r\nW= P(V2V1)\r\nwhich also gives P(V2V1) = R (ThTl)

  mvgnzls 20110907 18:01:05  why is there no n in the formulas?
pv=(n)RT & W= nRTln(vf/vi)
why do the n's get left out?
pam d 20110911 18:41:05 
n = 1, so you are right in looking for it but make sure you read the question very carefully

  jmason86 20090930 17:22:25  I also realized that therefore Q=W which is the area in the curve. However, the way I actually solved the problem was to look at the answers. (D) and (E) both had a first term that I knew was an isothermal work term. Also, the two answers were essentially identical, so the correct answer was probably one of those.
Looking at the 2nd terms, they obviously had different units. The units in the 2nd term of (D) are not consistent with the units in its first term.. you can't even do this subtraction. Eliminate (D). (E) remains.
noether 20091103 21:04:57 
Answer D does have correct units, see the responses to ssp's solution.

  mudder 20090928 02:13:31  An alternate way of looking at this is
Work = area of PV diagram
Since deltaU = o, then Q = area of PV diagram
Find the equation of the T_h isotherm using the ideal gas law, and integrate the PV region to find the area. That area is the added heat.   duckduck_85 20081106 16:43:43  radicaltyro's is the best and quickest solution   ssp 20080908 03:26:43  3step cycle with isovolumetric part that has W = 0, so we need an added heat for two steps (read two parts). That already eliminates (A) through (C). Then for the last part just dimensional analysis... (D) does not work cause we are missing a mass to convert the to joules.... that only leaves (E)
Walter 20090101 08:57:19 
Rejecting (D) on the grounds that we are "missing a mass" is not justified. The questions specifies that is a molar heat capacity and also that there is one mole of gas hence any term in the result would simplify to . Hence you remain stuck with a 50/50.
radicaltyro's solution is best.

okdisa 20090922 18:23:41 
Actually, so does in fact have the correct units. Don't forget that heat and energy are equivalent dimensionally.

Giuseppe 20150911 15:08:42 
You can\'t use dimensional analysis to eliminate choice D, it has the correct units. Cp is heat capacity at constant pressure per mole, and there is a factor of 1mole implicitaly multiplied everywhere in the solutions.

  kyros 20071101 11:27:59  Shouldn't the B>C term have a C_p not a C_v?
Imperate 20080904 09:38:50 
Yes.
B>C:
C>A:
Adding contributions from these parts, one obtains:
and remembering that for an ideal gas provides(setting n=1mole):
, which is the last term.

  radicaltyro 20061102 17:21:59  You don't need to calculate for each step. Just note that this is a cyclic process so and add up the 's.
newton 20070929 06:35:00 
cool solution

prismofmoonlight 20071101 23:30:12 
agreed.

tonyhong 20081004 04:24:55 
so there is nothing to do with Cp and Cv, answers B,C,D excluded. A is excluded for simple reason

wittensdog 20091016 15:23:50 
Indeed, I think I was almost implicitly doing this without even really thinking about it, but it's definitely a good general principle to remember.
The same idea applies for entropy, or any other state variable. As long as we're working with a constant amount of stuff, then things like pressure, volume, entropy, internal energy, and temperature are all specified when you choose a point on the PV diagram. So as long as you move around a closed loop, when you come back to the original point, then you end up with the same value as before. So indeed, when you go around the cycle, since you come back to the same point, you must have the same internal energy as before. This means that the heat added over the course of the cycle (eventually) all went into doing work. Of course this wouldn't be true in general if you just looked at a portion of the plot (though it is true for isotherms of ideal gases).

  beibei 20060614 12:40:26  Why I can not see the problems of 9677 15,16...only the solutions. some of the questions have this problem
godkun1 20170315 17:29:41 
You are right

 




The Sidebar Chatbox...
Scroll to see it, or resize your browser to ignore it... 

